Court upholds 52 Ukrtransbezpeka fines: the carrier failed to prove it was only a freight forwarder
The Eighth Administrative Court of Appeal, in case No. 460/11714/25, overturned the first-instance decision, dismissed a road carrier’s claim and upheld 52 fine decisions issued by Ukrtransbezpeka. The State Service of Ukraine for Transport Safety reported this on 20 November.
In short:
- during a roadside inspection in Volyn, vehicles of one carrier were found to exceed weight limits by 40–46%;
- 48 cases of drivers breaching work and rest time rules were recorded;
- cargo was carried without cargo documents and other documents required by law;
- Ukrtransbezpeka issued 52 decisions imposing fines;
- the entrepreneur claimed to be only a freight forwarder, but the appeal court disagreed.
What the inspection found
According to Ukrtransbezpeka, during a joint roadside inspection in Volyn, inspectors of the service and the patrol police found a number of violations in freight transport by vehicles of one carrier:
- exceeding weight limits by 40 to 46%;
- 48 cases of drivers breaching work and rest time rules;
- carriage of cargo without cargo documents and other documents required by law.
Following the review of the materials, 52 decisions imposing fines were issued.
Why the case went to court
The entrepreneur challenged the decisions. He argued that he acted only as a freight forwarder in the shipments and that the inspectors had wrongly identified the carrier. The court of first instance supported these arguments, but the appeal court found that conclusion to be wrong.
The appeal court’s position
As Ukrtransbezpeka reports, the panel of judges concluded that the service’s officials acted within the law and identified the carrier on the basis of primary documents provided during the inspection:
- consignment notes (TTN) — in all notes the claimant was named as both the carrier and the consignor, and he certified the accuracy of these data with his own signature and seal;
- insurance policies — in the compulsory motor third-party liability policies provided by the drivers, the claimant himself was named as the policyholder;
- type of activity — the entrepreneur’s main activity under the KVED classifier is 49.41 “Freight transport by road”.
The court was critical of the freight forwarding contracts and transport orders that the claimant provided later: the drivers did not have these documents during the roadside inspection, and the entrepreneur gave no evidence that they were actually performed — payments or acts of completed work.
The court also noted that, because of the two-month period set by law for considering the case, the supervisory body was obliged to decide on the materials available. An attempt to submit documents pointing to another carrier after that period expired does not remove liability.
What this means for carriers
In this case the court assessed the documents the drivers had at the time of the inspection: consignment notes, insurance policies and information about the type of activity.
Centr Avto can help with tachograph calibration and vehicle inspection: 098 500 5252.
FAQ
Why did the carrier receive 52 fine decisions?
According to Ukrtransbezpeka — for exceeding weight limits by 40–46%, 48 cases of drivers breaching work and rest time rules, and carrying cargo without documents.
Why did the court not recognise the entrepreneur as a forwarder?
In the consignment notes he was named as the carrier and the consignor, in the insurance policies as the policyholder, and his main activity is freight transport by road. The drivers had no forwarding contracts during the inspection.
Which court made the decision?
The Eighth Administrative Court of Appeal, case No. 460/11714/25.
Source: Ukrtransbezpeka, text of the ruling in the Unified State Register of Court Decisions (in Ukrainian)